On this page:

Analysis of the responses to the consultation document 'Towards a Mentally Flourishing Scotland'

« Previous | Contents | Next »

Listen

2 Description of respondents

2.1 The consultation received 76 written responses. However, one-quarter of these responses were submitted by representatives of multi-agency groups or partnership bodies. In many cases, these groups were specifically gathered for the purpose of commenting on the consultation paper, and their responses were collated and submitted by NHS Boards or local authorities. Annex 1 of this report provides a list of all the respondents to the consultation.

2.2 Table 1 below provides a breakdown of the responses by sector ( NHS, local authority, voluntary, etc)

Table 1: Breakdown of responses, by sector

n

%

Charity / voluntary sector

22

28.9%

Multi-agency groups or partnership bodies

19

25.0%

Service users / carers or their representatives

10

13.2%

NHS (including two individual GPs and one nurse)

6

7.9%

Local authorities

6

7.9%

Professional representative body (Royal Colleges, BMA, trade union)

5

6.6%

Other interested individuals

5

6.6%

Central government non-departmental public body

2

2.6%

Education

1

1.3%

76

100.0%

2.3 Just over a quarter of responses (28.9%) came from voluntary sector agencies or other charitable organisations. In most cases, these agencies had a national remit ( e.g., Alcohol Focus Scotland, Alzheimer Scotland, Depression Alliance Scotland, etc). Responses were also submitted by current and former mental health service users, carers or their representatives (13.2%).

2.4 As mentioned above, one-quarter of responses (25%) came from consultation exercises or events involving multi-agency groups or partnership bodies. Table 2 on the following page, provides an indication of the scale of these local consultations, and Annex 2 provides further details of the participants in local consultations.

2.5 Thirty-two respondents (42.1%) represented organisations with a national remit. These included, for example, NHS Health Scotland, NHS Education for Scotland, the Scottish Children's Reporter Association, professional representative bodies and trade unions, and many of the voluntary sector respondents. Thirty-one respondents (40.8%) represented organisations that had a remit within a local area. These included, for example, responses from local authorities, or locally organised multi-agency events and local service users' or carers groups. The remaining 13 responses (17.1%) came from individuals. These included individual service users, carers, doctors, nurses or other interested individuals.

2.6 Because such a large proportion of responses were submitted by multi-agency / partnership groups, no attempt has been made in this report to undertake an analysis of responses by sector. However, where a particular theme arose from within just one particular sector, this will be highlighted.

Table 2: Participation in multi-agency consultation exercises or events

Respondent (on behalf of multi-agency group or partnership)

Number of individuals participating in consultation

1

Alcohol Focus Scotland

Not stated

2

City of Edinburgh Council / NHS Lothian

Not stated

3

Dumfries & Galloway roundtable discussion on older adults' mental health

12

4

Dundee Community Transport & Dundee Accessible Transport Group

Not stated

5

Fife Health & Wellbeing Alliance

Not stated

6

NHS Ayrshire & Arran

208

7

NHS Borders / Scottish Borders Council

6

8

NHS Dumfries & Galloway

99 + collective responses from 2 groups

9

NHS Forth Valley

47

10

NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde

170

11

NHS Highland

Not stated

12

NHS Lanarkshire

165

13

NHS Lothian

130

14

NHS Orkney / Orkney Island Council

Not stated

15

NHS Tayside

100 (est)

16

North Ayrshire Choose Life Steering Group

Not stated

17

Orkney Disability Forum

Not stated

18

Scottish Association of Alcohol and Drug Action Teams

13

19

Shetland Mental Health Partnership

Not stated

« Previous | Contents | Next »

Page updated: Wednesday, May 21, 2008